American Appetites

People keep disappearing near Hanging Rock. Investigate where these lost souls have gone.

Rewards: +50 Fame, +15 Honor, Deadly Assassin Outfit scrap

Part 1

Speak with a woman next to the sheriff office in Armadillo. She'll explain that her son went missing in the hills near Hanging Rock and the people of the area did it. The sheriffs are not helpful so she pleads for your help instead.

Head out to the purple circle on your map to investigate. When you near the location the exact spot will be shown. Dismount your horse and search for clues by examining the objects on the ground. All that is found is some blood, a shoe, and bones. Part 1 is now complete.

Part 2

A day later speak with a man on the porch of the sheriff office. He too has a missing family member, his wife Beryl, who was picking mushrooms near Hanging Rock. Once again head out to the purple circle on your map. Searching for clues turns up more blood, a hat, and a human arm. Part 2 is now complete.

Part 3

Another day later there is another woman inside the Armadillo sheriff office. This time it's a husband who has gone missing out in the same place. Head out to the purple circle. This time you find a man (Randall Forrester) who says a city fella broke his leg and ran off.

Chase after the attacker on foot or by horse. Lasso and hogtie the man and then bring him back to the injured man. In the cutscene it is revealed that the injured man is actually a cannibal who was about to enjoy his next meal before it got away.

You are left to decide each man's fate. Allow the injured man to finish his meal by walking away or hogtie/kill him. In order to get the honor reward you must kill or hogtie the injured man. Walking away or killing the attacker will yield negative honor.

Tips

• The first two parts are simple.
• For the third part, have your lasso equipped before talking to the injured man.
• Right after the cutscene sprint forward, aim, and throw your lasso at the attacker. You should be able to get him before he has a chance to run more than a few feet.